Roswell Mayor Dennis Kintigh was shocked when the New Mexico Department of Health (DOH) didn’t include Eddy County in loosening some COVID-19 public health restrictions.
Chaves and Lea counties moved from red (very high risk) to yellow (high risk) Wednesday as the State of New Mexico adjusted rules of public health orders based on county-level prevalence of COVID-19 and test positivity.
Eddy County wasn’t as fortunate as its northern and eastern neighbors and was one of four New Mexico counties in red.
More:111 now dead from COVID-19 in Eddy County
Data from DOH indicated Chaves county’s daily cases per 100,000 was 11.80 and the positivity rate was 3.22 percent. Lea county’s daily cases per 100,000 was 9.60 with a positivity rate of 4.76 percent.
Eddy county’s daily cases per 100,000 was 17.70 and the positivity rate was 5.85 percent, read DOH figures.
The state’s county-by-county system uses key health metrics – the per-capita daily incidence of new COVID-19 cases and average COVID-19 test positivity within county borders – to determine the level of public health risk and requirement for each county, read a DOH news release.
A county that meets one criterion may operate at the yellow level; a county that meets both may operate at the green level. A county that has met both for two consecutive biweekly map updates may operate at the turquoise level.
More:Eddy County works to increase COVID-19 vaccine clinics in Carlsbad
“I don’t know why there’s a disparity between Chaves County and Eddy County,” Kintigh said. “I don’t get it. Supposedly Chaves is in the yellow because our positivity rate on testing is below the five percent. I can’t confirm that independently, the data I’m looking shows number of cases the exceeds the 8 per 100,000. So, I did not expect us to make yellow.”
Kintigh said it’s going to be hard for Chaves County to get the green level, which is medium risk.
“Because of the size of our population we would have to average five cases per day for two weeks and the two-week period before yesterday (Wednesday) was some where around 10 cases, so we’d have to cut it in half,” he said.
“I don’t see how were going to get there to meet the governor’s requirements. But, she’s the governor,” Kintigh said.
More:Eddy County Walmarts are COVID-19 vaccine providers
Lea County State Rep. Randy Pettigrew (R-61) said anything that opens businesses and allows residents to make decisions on what they want “is a good thing.”
“This doesn’t do that. This still controls very specifically what can and can’t happen in the state and I think she (Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham) overreaches when she does that,” he said.
Like Kintigh, Pettigrew doesn’t understand why Eddy County remained high risk. He said Lea County has made a big push to get people tested.
“To the point where there’s a multitude of people in Lea County that are getting tested twice a week,” he said. “They know they’re negative, but they keep testing because you’ve got to turn a ruler into a yard stick to make it work.”
State Sen. David Gallegos (R-41) represents Lea and Eddy counties and was perplexed by the figures as well.
More:Carlsbad Mayor: Local COVID-19 numbers improving
“I just don’t understand it. Everything I saw in Lea and Eddy counties numbers were on the right on the right trajectory,” he said.
Gallegos said he couldn’t understand how Lujan Grisham was “doing the math” when it comes to COVID-19 figures in New Mexico.
Ward 3 Carlsbad City Councilor Jason Shirley said the State of New Mexico is taking major steps and it’s time to get the economy at full capacity.
“I’m happy to see a path forward beyond green, though I would like to have seen what complete reopening would look like. Other states have proven that there are responsible paths to full capacity sooner rather than later,” he said.
Shirley said Wednesday’s numbers were very close in getting Eddy County to yellow.
More:Eddy County remains in red in latest New Mexico COVID-19 outlook
“But really close doesn’t help our restaurants who are fighting for their lives right now,” he said.
Carlsbad Mayor Dale Janway agreed with Shirley as Eddy County missed the yellow mark by a small percentage.
“The New Mexico Department of Health reported a 5.8 percent positivity rate over the past two weeks, while a 5 percent positivity rate is one of the possible requirements. Being close, of course, does not help our restaurants with opening for indoor dining over the next two weeks or any of our other businesses who are struggling,” he said.
Janway said the increase in the number of vaccines being distributed and the significant downward trend in COVID-19 cases, The City of Carlsbad believes it is certainly past time for all New Mexico communities to be allowed to open much more significantly.
Mike Smith can be reached at 575-628-5546 or by email at [email protected] or @ArgusMichae on Twitter.